ER MDs Order Unnecessary Tests Due to Malpractice Fears, New Study Contends

April 26, 2015

Many emergency room physicians order expensive diagnostic tests on patients who may not need them out of fear they may end up being sued for medical malpractice, a recently published study contends. This study, which was led and authored by Dr. Hemal Kanzaria (an ER doctor at UCLA), focused on surveying more than 430 ER doctors – 97 percent of whom stated that they have ordered advanced imaging tests on patients who may not have needed them.

ER docs order too many imaging tests due to fears of being sued, a new study reports. Our Portland medical malpractice lawyer points out some shortcomings of this study.

ER docs order too many imaging tests due to fears of being sued, a new study reports. Our Portland medical malpractice lawyer points out some shortcomings of this study.

Here’s what else this study found:

  • Unnecessary imaging scans, as well as the treatments recommended as a result of these tests, cost about $210 billion annually.
  • When imaging tests are unnecessary for patients, they can expose patients to some significant risks, including the risk of getting “false positive” results, exposing patients to treatments that may do more harm than good, etc.

Commenting on these findings, Kanzaria stated, “[Doctors] don’t like uncertainty, and so we’re driven by this culture that says if there’s any doubt, we should do the test, and we don’t acknowledge the potential harms of this approach.”

In the conclusion to this study, Kanzaria recommended improving patient education and including patients in the decision-making process (so that patients can decide whether they need advanced imaging tests).

Failure to Diagnosis, Misdiagnoses Not Discussed in Study

While this study may have underscored that there could be some extra costs and risks associated with performing advanced, unnecessary imaging tests, interestingly, it did not include a discussion of the fact that failure to diagnose and misdiagnoses are often a problem among ER doctors. In fact, some research has found that ER diagnostic errors impact between 20 and 40 percent of patients treated in these facilities.

Additionally, this study seems to have fallen short in:

  • Suggesting just how and when ER doctors are supposed to deem that testing is unnecessary
  • Discussing (or recommending) just how patient education and inclusion in the decision-making process would even work, especially considering the fact that people who need emergency medical treatment may not be conscious, etc.

What do you think about this study’s findings? Share your thoughts with us on Facebook and Google+.

Portland Medical Malpractice Lawyer at the Savage Law Firm

Have you been hurt by any type of medical negligence? If so, you can rely on an experienced Portland medical malpractice attorneys at the Savage Law Firm for experienced help and aggressive legal advocacy. Since 1977, our lawyers have been devoted to providing each of our clients with personal attention, respect and the highest quality legal services.

We realize how devastating medical malpractice can be on a physical, as well as a psychological and financial, level. That is why our lawyers are here to aggressively defend injured people’s rights to both justice and compensation. 

To learn more about our legal services and what we can do for you, call us at 503-222-0200 (in Portland) or at 206-957-7272 (in Seattle). You can also email us using the form on this page. We represent clients in communities in both Oregon and Washington from our offices in Portland and Seattle.

Categories: Malpractice